Prerequisites
Before attempting this problem, you should be comfortable with:
- Hash Set - Used for O(1) lookup to efficiently check if an element's successor exists
- Array Traversal - Iterating through arrays and understanding linear search complexity
- Sorting - Understanding how sorting brings related elements together for optimized approaches
1. Search with Array
Intuition
For each element x in the array, we need to check whether x + 1 also exists in the array. The straightforward approach is to scan through the entire array for each element to verify if its successor is present. While this works correctly, it requires a linear search for every element.
Algorithm
- Initialize a counter to
0. - For each element
xin the array, iterate through the array to check ifx + 1exists. - If
x + 1is found, increment the counter. - Return the final count.
Time & Space Complexity
- Time complexity:
- Space complexity: constant space
Where is the length of the input array
arr.
2. Search with HashSet
Intuition
The brute force approach is slow because checking if x + 1 exists requires scanning the entire array. A hash set provides O(1) lookup time, so we can first store all elements in a set, then check for each element's successor in constant time.
Algorithm
- Insert all elements from the array into a hash set.
- Initialize a counter to
0. - For each element
xin the array, check ifx + 1exists in the hash set. - If it does, increment the counter.
- Return the final count.
Time & Space Complexity
- Time complexity:
- Space complexity:
Where is the length of the input array
arr.
3. Search with Sorted Array
Intuition
Sorting brings equal elements together and places consecutive values next to each other. After sorting, we can traverse the array once and track "runs" of identical values. When we encounter a new value that is exactly one more than the previous value, all elements in the previous run satisfy the condition.
Algorithm
- Sort the array.
- Initialize a counter and a run length tracker (starting at
1). - Iterate through the sorted array starting from index
1. - If the current element differs from the previous one:
- If the current element equals the previous element plus
1, add the run length to the counter. - Reset the run length to
0.
- If the current element equals the previous element plus
- Increment the run length for each element processed.
- Return the final count.
Time & Space Complexity
- Time complexity:
- Space complexity: varies from to
- The overall space complexity is dependent on the space complexity of the sorting algorithm you're using. The space complexity of sorting algorithms built into programming languages are generally anywhere from to .
Where is the length of the input array
arr.
Common Pitfalls
Checking for x - 1 Instead of x + 1
The problem asks to count elements x where x + 1 exists in the array. A common mistake is checking for x - 1 instead, which counts elements that have a predecessor rather than a successor.
# Wrong: Checking for predecessor
if x - 1 in hash_set:
count += 1
# Correct: Checking for successor
if x + 1 in hash_set:
count += 1Counting Unique Values Instead of All Occurrences
The problem asks to count every element x where x + 1 exists, including duplicates. Using a set for counting instead of iterating through the original array will miss duplicate elements.
# Wrong: Only counts unique values
hash_set = set(arr)
count = sum(1 for x in hash_set if x + 1 in hash_set)
# Correct: Count all occurrences including duplicates
hash_set = set(arr)
count = sum(1 for x in arr if x + 1 in hash_set)