1857. Largest Color Value in a Directed Graph - Explanation

Problem Link



Prerequisites

Before attempting this problem, you should be comfortable with:

  • Graph Representation - Building adjacency lists from edge lists for directed graphs
  • Depth-First Search (DFS) - Traversing graphs and tracking visited nodes to avoid infinite loops
  • Cycle Detection - Identifying cycles in directed graphs using path tracking during DFS
  • Topological Sort - Processing nodes in dependency order using Kahn's algorithm (BFS with indegree)
  • Dynamic Programming on Graphs - Propagating and aggregating values (color counts) along graph paths

1. Brute Force (DFS)

Intuition

The problem asks for the maximum count of any single color along any valid path in the graph. A direct approach is to try every possible starting node and every possible color, then use DFS to explore all paths and count how many nodes of that color we encounter. If we detect a cycle during DFS, the answer is -1 since valid paths cannot contain cycles.

Algorithm

  1. Build an adjacency list from the edges.
  2. For each node from 0 to n-1, and for each color from 0 to 25:
    • Run DFS from that node, tracking visited nodes in the current path to detect cycles.
    • Count nodes matching the target color along the path.
    • If a cycle is detected, return -1 immediately.
    • Track the maximum color count found.
  3. Return the maximum count.
class Solution:
    def largestPathValue(self, colors: str, edges: list[list[int]]) -> int:
        n = len(colors)
        adj = [[] for _ in range(n)]
        for u, v in edges:
            adj[u].append(v)

        visit = [False] * n
        def dfs(node, c):
            if visit[node]:
                return float("inf")

            visit[node] = True
            clrCnt = 0
            for nei in adj[node]:
                cur = dfs(nei, c)
                if cur == float("inf"):
                    return cur
                clrCnt = max(clrCnt, cur)
            visit[node] = False
            return clrCnt + (c == (ord(colors[node]) - ord('a')))

        res = -1
        for i in range(n):
            for c in range(26):
                cnt = dfs(i, c)
                if cnt == float("inf"):
                    return -1
                res = max(res, cnt)
        return res

Time & Space Complexity

  • Time complexity: O(V(V+E))O(V * (V + E))
  • Space complexity: O(V+E)O(V + E)

Where VV is the number of verticies and EE is the number of edges.


Intuition

Instead of checking one color at a time, we can track all 26 color counts simultaneously for each node. Using memoization, once we compute the maximum color counts reachable from a node, we store and reuse that result. We use two sets: one for globally visited nodes (already fully processed) and one for the current DFS path (to detect cycles).

Algorithm

  1. Build an adjacency list from the edges.
  2. Create a 2D array count[node][color] to store the maximum count of each color reachable from each node.
  3. For each node, run DFS:
    • If the node is in the current path, a cycle exists; return infinity.
    • If already fully visited, return 0.
    • Mark the node as in the current path and initialize its own color count to 1.
    • For each neighbor, recursively compute counts and update the current node's counts by taking the maximum.
    • Remove the node from the current path after processing.
  4. Return the maximum value across all count[node][color], or -1 if a cycle was detected.
class Solution:
    def largestPathValue(self, colors: str, edges: list[list[int]]) -> int:
        adj = defaultdict(list)
        for src, dst in edges:
            adj[src].append(dst)

        def dfs(node):
            if node in path:
                return float("inf")
            if node in visit:
                return 0

            visit.add(node)
            path.add(node)
            colorIndex = ord(colors[node]) - ord('a')
            count[node][colorIndex] = 1

            for nei in adj[node]:
                if dfs(nei) == float("inf"):
                    return float("inf")
                for c in range(26):
                    count[node][c] = max(
                        count[node][c],
                        (1 if c == colorIndex else 0) + count[nei][c]
                    )

            path.remove(node)
            return 0

        n, res = len(colors), 0
        visit, path = set(), set()
        count = [[0] * 26 for _ in range(n)]

        for i in range(n):
            if dfs(i) == float("inf"):
                return -1
            res = max(res, max(count[i]))

        return res

Time & Space Complexity

  • Time complexity: O(V+E)O(V + E)
  • Space complexity: O(V+E)O(V + E)

Where VV is the number of verticies and EE is the number of edges.


3. Topological Sort (Kahn's Algorithm)

Intuition

Since we need valid paths in a directed graph, topological sorting naturally fits. We process nodes in topological order using Kahn's algorithm (BFS with indegree tracking). For each node, we propagate color counts to its neighbors before they are processed. If we cannot process all nodes, a cycle exists. This approach avoids recursion and handles cycle detection elegantly.

Algorithm

  1. Build an adjacency list and compute the indegree of each node.
  2. Initialize a 2D array count[node][color] for tracking color frequencies.
  3. Add all nodes with indegree 0 to a queue.
  4. Process nodes in BFS order:
    • Increment the count for the node's own color.
    • Update the result with this color count.
    • For each neighbor, propagate the current node's color counts, then decrement the neighbor's indegree. If it becomes 0, add it to the queue.
  5. If the number of processed nodes equals n, return the result. Otherwise, return -1 (cycle detected).
class Solution:
    def largestPathValue(self, colors: str, edges: list[list[int]]) -> int:
        n = len(colors)
        adj = [[] for _ in range(n)]
        indegree = [0] * n
        count = [[0] * 26 for _ in range(n)]

        for u, v in edges:
            adj[u].append(v)
            indegree[v] += 1

        q = deque()
        for i in range(n):
            if indegree[i] == 0:
                q.append(i)

        visit = res = 0
        while q:
            node = q.popleft()
            visit += 1
            colorIndex = ord(colors[node]) - ord('a')
            count[node][colorIndex] += 1
            res = max(res, count[node][colorIndex])

            for nei in adj[node]:
                for c in range(26):
                    count[nei][c] = max(count[nei][c], count[node][c])

                indegree[nei] -= 1
                if indegree[nei] == 0:
                    q.append(nei)

        return res if visit == n else -1

Time & Space Complexity

  • Time complexity: O(V+E)O(V + E)
  • Space complexity: O(V+E)O(V + E)

Where VV is the number of verticies and EE is the number of edges.


Common Pitfalls

Failing to Detect Cycles

The problem requires returning -1 if the graph contains a cycle, since cycles mean there are infinitely long paths. A common mistake is forgetting to track the current DFS path separately from globally visited nodes. Using only a single visited set will not distinguish between nodes that are ancestors in the current path (indicating a cycle) versus nodes that were visited in a completely different traversal.

Confusing Path Tracking with Global Visited

When using DFS with memoization, you need two separate tracking mechanisms: one for nodes currently in the recursion stack (to detect cycles) and one for nodes that have been fully processed (to avoid recomputation). Mixing these up leads to either false cycle detection or infinite loops.

Not Propagating Color Counts Correctly

When computing the maximum color count for a node, you must consider the counts from all reachable nodes, not just immediate neighbors. The DP state count[node][color] should represent the maximum count of that color on any path starting from that node. Forgetting to take the maximum across all neighbors or failing to add the current node's color contribution leads to incorrect results.

Processing Nodes Before All Predecessors Are Complete

In the topological sort approach, a node should only be processed after all its incoming edges have been handled. If you process a node too early (before all predecessors have propagated their color counts), you'll miss potential maximum values from paths that haven't been fully computed yet.

Off-by-One Errors in Color Indexing

Colors are given as lowercase letters but need to be converted to indices 0-25 for array access. A common bug is incorrectly converting characters (e.g., forgetting to subtract 'a') or mixing up when to add the current node's color contribution (should be added exactly once per node on the path).