Prerequisites
Before attempting this problem, you should be comfortable with:
- String Parsing - Extracting characters and numeric values from a formatted string
- Iterator Pattern - Understanding how iterators maintain state between successive calls
- Arrays/Lists - Using dynamic arrays to store precomputed results
1. Uncompressing the String (Time Limit Exceeded)
Intuition
The most straightforward approach is to fully decompress the string during initialization. We parse each character-count pair and append the character that many times to a result array. Then iteration simply walks through this precomputed array. This is easy to implement but can use excessive memory and time when counts are very large.
Algorithm
- Parse the compressed string, extracting each character followed by its numeric count.
- For each pair, append the character to a result array the specified number of times.
- Maintain a pointer
ptrstarting at0. - For
next(): IfhasNext()isfalse, return a space. Otherwise, return the character atptrand incrementptr. - For
hasNext(): Returntrueifptris less than the length of the result array.
class StringIterator:
def __init__(self, compressedString: str):
self.res = []
self.ptr = 0
i = 0
while i < len(compressedString):
ch = compressedString[i]
i += 1
num = 0
while i < len(compressedString) and compressedString[i].isdigit():
num = num * 10 + int(compressedString[i])
i += 1
for j in range(num):
self.res.append(ch)
def next(self) -> str:
if not self.hasNext():
return ' '
char = self.res[self.ptr]
self.ptr += 1
return char
def hasNext(self) -> bool:
return self.ptr != len(self.res)Time & Space Complexity
We precompute the elements of the uncompressed string. Thus, the space required in this case is , where refers to the length of the uncompressed string.
The time required for precomputation is since we need to generate the uncompressed string of length .
Once the precomputation has been done, the time required for performing
next()andhasNext()is for both.This approach can be easily extended to include
previous(),last()andfind()operations. All these operations require the use of an index only and thus, take time. Operations likehasPrevious()can also be easily included.Since once the precomputation has been done,
next()requires time, this approach is useful ifnext()operation needs to be performed a large number of times. However, ifhasNext()is performed most of the times, this approach isn't much advantageous since precomputation needs to be done anyhow.A potential problem with this approach could arise if the length of the uncompressed string is very large. In such a case, the size of the complete uncompressed string could become so large that it can't fit in the memory limits, leading to memory overflow.
Where is the length of the uncompressed string.
2. Pre-Computation
Intuition
Instead of fully decompressing, we can store the compressed representation more efficiently by separating characters and their counts into parallel arrays. During iteration, we track which character group we're in and how many of that character remain. When a count reaches zero, we move to the next group. This uses space proportional to the compressed string rather than the decompressed length.
Algorithm
- Parse the compressed string using regex or manual parsing to extract two arrays:
chars(the letters) andnums(the counts). - Maintain a pointer
ptrto the current character group. - For
next(): IfhasNext()isfalse, return a space. Otherwise, decrementnums[ptr], get the character atchars[ptr], and ifnums[ptr]becomes0, incrementptr. Return the character. - For
hasNext(): Returntrueifptris less than the length ofchars.
class StringIterator:
def __init__(self, compressedString: str):
self.ptr = 0
import re
self.nums = list(map(int, re.findall(r'\d+', compressedString)))
self.chars = re.findall(r'[a-zA-Z]', compressedString)
def next(self) -> str:
if not self.hasNext():
return ' '
self.nums[self.ptr] -= 1
res = self.chars[self.ptr]
if self.nums[self.ptr] == 0:
self.ptr += 1
return res
def hasNext(self) -> bool:
return self.ptr != len(self.chars)Time & Space Complexity
The space required for storing the results of the precomputation is , where refers to the length of the compressed string. The and array contain a total of elements.
The precomputation step requires time. Thus, if
hasNext()operation is performed most of the times, this precomputation turns out to be non-advantageous.Once the precomputation has been done,
hasNext()andnext()require time.This approach can be extended to include the
previous()andhasPrevious()operations, but that would require making some simple modifications to the current implementation.
Where is the length of the compressed string.
3. Demand-Computation
Intuition
The most space-efficient approach avoids any preprocessing. We store the original compressed string and parse it lazily as we iterate. We keep track of the current character and how many times it should still be returned. When that count reaches zero, we parse the next character-count pair from the string on demand.
Algorithm
- Store the compressed string. Initialize
ptr = 0,num = 0, andch = ' '. - For
next(): IfhasNext()isfalse, return a space. Ifnumis0, parse the next character (store inch) and its following digits (store innum). Decrementnumand returnch. - For
hasNext(): Returntrueifptris less than the string length ORnumis greater than0.
class StringIterator:
def __init__(self, compressedString: str):
self.res = compressedString
self.ptr = 0
self.num = 0
self.ch = ' '
def next(self) -> str:
if not self.hasNext():
return ' '
if self.num == 0:
self.ch = self.res[self.ptr]
self.ptr += 1
while self.ptr < len(self.res) and self.res[self.ptr].isdigit():
self.num = self.num * 10 + int(self.res[self.ptr])
self.ptr += 1
self.num -= 1
return self.ch
def hasNext(self) -> bool:
return self.ptr != len(self.res) or self.num != 0Time & Space Complexity
Since no precomputation is done, constant space is required in this case.
The time required to perform
next()operation is .The time required for
hasNext()operation is .Since no precomputations are done, and
hasNext()requires only time, this solution is advantageous ifhasNext()operation is performed most of the times.This approach can be extended to include
previous()andhasPrevious()operations, but this will require the use of some additional variables.
Common Pitfalls
Not Handling Multi-Digit Counts
Counts can be more than one digit (e.g., "a12" means 12 a's). A common mistake is reading only a single digit.
# Wrong - only reads single digit
def next(self) -> str:
if self.num == 0:
self.ch = self.res[self.ptr]
self.ptr += 1
self.num = int(self.res[self.ptr]) # Fails for "a12"
self.ptr += 1
self.num -= 1
return self.ch
# Correct - parse all consecutive digits
def next(self) -> str:
if self.num == 0:
self.ch = self.res[self.ptr]
self.ptr += 1
while self.ptr < len(self.res) and self.res[self.ptr].isdigit():
self.num = self.num * 10 + int(self.res[self.ptr])
self.ptr += 1
self.num -= 1
return self.chIncorrect hasNext() Logic with Demand Computation
When using lazy parsing, hasNext() must check both whether unparsed string remains AND whether current character still has remaining count.
# Wrong - only checks string position
def hasNext(self) -> bool:
return self.ptr != len(self.res) # Misses remaining count!
# Correct - check both conditions
def hasNext(self) -> bool:
return self.ptr != len(self.res) or self.num != 0