Prerequisites
Before attempting this problem, you should be comfortable with:
- Combinatorics Basics - Understanding how to count combinations and permutations for distribution problems
- Enumeration Techniques - Iterating through all valid possibilities systematically
- Inclusion-Exclusion Principle - Computing counts by adding/subtracting overlapping sets to avoid overcounting
1. Brute Force
Intuition
The most straightforward approach is to try every possible combination of candies for the three children. We iterate through all values for child A, child B, and child C (each from 0 to the limit), and count only those combinations where the total equals exactly n candies. While simple to understand, this method checks many invalid combinations.
Algorithm
- Initialize a counter
resto0. - Use three nested loops to iterate through all possible candy amounts for each child (
0tolimit). - For each combination
(a, b, c), check ifa + b + c == n. - If
true, increment the counter. - Return the total count.
Time & Space Complexity
- Time complexity:
- Space complexity:
Where is the given limit.
2. Better Approach
Intuition
We can reduce unnecessary iterations by fixing the first child's amount and only looping through valid values for the second child. Once we know how many candies child A and child B receive, child C's amount is determined: c = n - a - b. We simply check if this value is within the allowed limit.
Algorithm
- Initialize a counter
resto0. - Loop through possible values for
afrom0tomin(n, limit). - For each
a, loop through possible values forbfrom0tomin(n - a, limit). - Calculate
c = n - a - b. Ifc <= limit, increment the counter. - Return the total count.
Time & Space Complexity
- Time complexity:
- Space complexity:
3. Enumeration - I
Intuition
Instead of iterating through every value of b, we can directly compute the range of valid values. For a fixed a, child B can receive anywhere from b_min to b_max candies, where b_max = min(n - a, limit) and b_min = max(0, n - a - limit). The lower bound ensures child C does not exceed the limit. The number of valid b values is simply b_max - b_min + 1.
Algorithm
- Initialize a counter
resto0. - Loop through possible values for
afrom0tomin(n, limit). - For each
a, computeb_max = min(n - a, limit)andb_min = max(0, n - a - limit). - If
b_max >= b_min, add(b_max - b_min + 1)to the counter. - Return the total count.
Time & Space Complexity
- Time complexity:
4. Enumeration - II
Intuition
This is a slight optimization of the previous approach. We add an early check: if the remaining candies n - a exceeds 2 * limit, it is impossible to distribute them between child B and child C (since each can hold at most limit). This allows us to skip invalid values of a entirely.
Algorithm
- Initialize a counter
resto0. - Loop through possible values for
afrom0tomin(n, limit). - Let
rem = n - a. Ifrem > 2 * limit, skip this iteration. - Otherwise, compute the number of valid
(b, c)pairs asmin(rem, limit) - max(0, rem - limit) + 1. - Add this count to
res. - Return the total count.
Time & Space Complexity
- Time complexity:
5. Inclusion-Exclusion Principle
Intuition
We can solve this in constant time using combinatorics. The total number of ways to distribute n candies among 3 children (without the limit constraint) is C(n+2, 2). However, we need to subtract cases where at least one child exceeds the limit. Using the inclusion-exclusion principle, we subtract cases where one child exceeds the limit, add back cases where two children exceed it (since they were subtracted twice), and subtract cases where all three exceed it.
Algorithm
- Define the binomial coefficient for choosing 2 from
m+2as(m+2)*(m+1)/2. - For
jfrom0to3, calculatem = n - j * (limit + 1). - If
m < 0, skip this term. - Compute
ways = (m+2)*(m+1)/2. - Apply alternating signs using the inclusion-exclusion pattern and multiply by
C(3, j). - Sum all terms and return the result.
Time & Space Complexity
- Time complexity:
- Space complexity:
Common Pitfalls
Forgetting the Lower Bound for Child C
When calculating valid values for child B, you must ensure child C does not exceed the limit. The lower bound b_min = max(0, n - a - limit) ensures that c = n - a - b stays within bounds.
# Wrong: Only checking upper bound
for b in range(min(n - a, limit) + 1):
c = n - a - b
if c >= 0: # Missing: c <= limit check!
res += 1
# Correct: Check both bounds
b_max = min(n - a, limit)
b_min = max(0, n - a - limit) # Ensures c <= limit
if b_max >= b_min:
res += b_max - b_min + 1Off-by-One Errors in Loop Bounds
When iterating through candy values, remember that both 0 and limit are valid amounts. Using range(limit) instead of range(limit + 1) misses the case where a child gets exactly limit candies.
# Wrong: Missing limit value
for a in range(limit): # Goes 0 to limit-1
...
# Correct: Include limit
for a in range(limit + 1): # Goes 0 to limit
...
# Also correct: Use min(n, limit) for optimization
for a in range(min(n, limit) + 1):
...Incorrect Inclusion-Exclusion Signs
The inclusion-exclusion principle requires alternating signs: add for 0 violations, subtract for 1 violation, add for 2 violations, subtract for 3 violations. Getting the sign wrong produces incorrect results.
# Wrong: All additions
for j in range(4):
res += C3[j] * ways # Should alternate signs!
# Correct: Alternating signs based on j
for j in range(4):
sign = 1 if j % 2 == 0 else -1
res += sign * C3[j] * ways